Who You Talk To
Wednesday May 23, 2007
Years ago, when I was a brash young writer, I was sent to
Brazil. In those days, Brazil was firmly in the clutch of the military.
Thanks to church connections, I met people who would otherwise never have
talked to me. I wouldn't even have known how to contact them.
So I talked to Fred Morris, a Methodist pastor. Fred introduced me
to Catholic archbishop Helder Camara, a chronic burr under the military
saddle. Camara got me into a blood donor clinic, run by his church, really
functioning as a birth control clinic.
Fred Morris said it was dangerous for him to talk to me. I didn't
realize how dangerous, until later. The police came for him. He was
arrested. Imprisoned without trial. Beaten. Tortured, with electrodes
clipped to his testicles.
I talked to a labor lawyer. He wouldn't talk in his apartment. He
wouldn't come to my host's apartment. He would only talk while we strolled
in a park. Near a playground, with children's voices shrilling around us. To
avoid electronic eavesdropping.
I talked to people in squalid favelas. Family members had
disappeared. By coincidence, they had protested their conditions shortly
before.
I talked to their pastors. I heard about the pressures that
prevented people from speaking out.
Different credentials
Not long before, I had worked in a
Canadian radio station. As a reporter, I made friends with the local RCMP
detachment. I went jogging with them, three times a week. I drank beer with
the staff sergeant.
In Brazil, I realized how different his contacts would have been
from mine. He belonged to Rotary. He was on the executive of the local
Chamber of Commerce. He would have visited boardrooms and management suites.
He would have been welcome in police stations and army barracks.
He would have encountered quite a different Brazil.
The truth often depends on who you talk to. You'll get quite a
different story from Jews in Jerusalem, than from Palestinians in Gaza.
Around the time that apartheid was collapsing in South Africa, I was
assigned to interview some Canadian bank executives. They felt unfairly
under fire. Canadian churches were protesting against Canadian banks loaning
Canadian money to support a racist regime in South Africa.
It was good business, the bankers insisted. According to their
sources, South Africa was thriving.
Creating credibility
Business people talk to other business
people. Diplomats talk to other diplomats. Nobody important talks to the
nobodies.
History suggests that the churches of the world, committed to
working with the people, have often grasped truth better than people who
inhabit walnut-panelled boardrooms.
The most important function of the worldwide Christian church may
not be weekly worship. Or prayer. Or even fund-raising for good causes –
service clubs do that as effectively. The church's most important function
may be its international network of connections.
Other groups also work with people at ground level - social workers,
teachers, nurses ... But they often lack an international structure that
enables people in other countries to hear their story – and to believe it. |

Jim Taylor
Jim Taylor has more than 40 years experience writing and editing, in
broadcasting, magazines, newspapers, and books. He was for 13 years the managing
editor of a 330,000 circulation magazine; he co-founded a publishing house; he
has written 13 books and has lost count of the number of magazine articles.
Although theoretically retired, he continues to edit two or three books a year,
dispenses advice liberally, and teaches his Eight-Step Editing workshops across
Canada. |