Doing Without

  Jim Taylor's Soft Edges

Lectionary Analysis.......................Soft Edges Commentary.........................Reflections on Life and Faith

Jim Taylor has more than 40 years experience writing and editing, in broadcasting, magazines, newspapers, and books. He was for 13 years the managing editor of a 330,000 circulation magazine; he co-founded a publishing house; he has written 13 books and has lost count of the number of magazine articles. Although theoretically retired, he continues to edit two or three books a year, dispenses advice liberally, and teaches his Eight-Step Editing workshops across Canada.


To receive David's Seems Like God blog by email. enter your address:


Delivered by FeedBurner
Visit the Golden Rule - a Global Ethic for a Global Civilization
Seems Like God

 

Doing Without

Wednesday March 1, 2006

Today, most Christians in the western world begin the Season of Lent.
        When I was young, Christians were expected to give up something for Lent.
        First, as a sign of repentance. By punishing ourselves, we showed a supposedly loving God that we were sorry for whatever we had done that we shouldn't have done, on the assumption that making ourselves miserable would make God happy.
        My first boss had a gorgeous secretary. She passed my desk every time she entered or left his office. I almost swooned. But during Lent, she looked haggard. She had given up cosmetics.
        I'm still not sure how that pleased God. It certainly didn't please me!

Shared suffering
        Second, as sharing in Christ's suffering. Traditionally, this meant fasting – doing without meat, sometimes also without fish, eggs, and milk products.
        Some claim this custom had less to do with religion than with the lack of refrigeration. By late winter, perishable products had often thawed, frozen, and thawed again. Doing without them was safer than food poisoning.
        I'm still not sure how weakening our bodies made Jesus feel better, though.
        Third, as self-discipline. By refusing to succumb to temptation, we re-enact Jesus' temptations in the desert.
        According to the Bible, Jesus spent 40 days in the wilderness, doing without food, while being tempted by the devil. That's why Lent lasts for 40 days, not counting Sundays – although Jesus didn't get Sundays off while he was being tempted.
        But the “40” was a symbolic figure. The rain came down for 40 days in Noah's flood. Moses spent 40 days up the mountain gathering the Commandments. The Hebrew people wandered 40 years in the desert after escaping from Egypt. Isaac was 40 when he married Rebecca. Goliath taunted the Israelite armies for 40 days. Both David and Solomon, by amazing coincidence, ruled Israel for 40 years…
        For a people who lacked computers to keep digital records of every detail of life, 40 simply stood for “a very long time.”

Making God happy
        Perhaps you can infer that I'm skeptical about traditional Lenten practices?
        You see, I do not believe that God wants us to be miserable. I do not believe that God wants us to suffer for our own good. I do not believe that God punishes us by inflicting disease and death upon us.
        If God does punish us – and that's a very big “if” – then it's equally possible that God punishes by granting some people wealth and fame. They can never have confidence that their friends are not just sycophants sucking up. They cannot sustain long-term relationships. Their enemies constantly try to topple them off their pedestals…
        If I'm going to give up something, I want it to be for my own good. So that I can be a healthier, wiser, more caring person. And perhaps what I am no longer greedy for, I can share with others.
        I believe that will make God much happier than watching me avoid chocolates.



Copyright ©  by Jim Taylor. Non-profit use in congregations and study groups permitted; all other rights reserved.
To send comments on this column, email Jim Taylor directly. You can also receive Jim's column by email. Contact him at jimt@quixotic.ca



Golden Rule Radical | Seems Like God | About this SiteContact |