More Than a Birdbrain
Wednesday September 20, 2006
I had a conversation with a crow
earlier this year.
I had been taking the dog for her morning walk. A crow in a tree
overhead starting giving us a lecture – that monotonous and repetitious
cawing.
I stopped, and started talking to the crow.
The cawing stopped. The crow began making different noises. They
certainly weren't speech, in any form that I could understand. But the range
of tones, the variety of inflections, the apparently deliberate articulation
of non-standard sounds, suggested that this crow was genuinely trying to
communicate something.
Most of the sounds were what linguistics experts would call vowels,
rather than consonants – although there were a few plosives and fricatives
too. They were mostly the broader vowels – somewhere between “ah” and “aw,”
with no “ee” or “oo” sounds.
Perhaps it was just mimicking me. That's always possible. But even
that's a sign of intelligence. Our human infants start by imitating what
must to them be meaningless sounds. And we consider that a sign of budding
intelligence.
Capabilities
I am personally
becoming more and more impressed by the intelligence of birds in general. At
the very least, they can work in three dimensions far beyond human capacity.
No human being, from astronaut to helicopter pilot, could drop a plane right
onto a runway that was thrashing back and forth like a snake that had just
swallowed a jalapeno pepper. Every bird can, when it lands on a twig tossed
by a gusty wind.
I am particularly impressed by the corvid family, which includes
ravens, crows, and magpies.
Humorist Lorne Elliott describes hearing what sounded like a
convention of feathered creatures on the other side of a hedge – every
conceivable kind of squawk, tweet and whistle. He peered through, and found
a single magpie, amusing itself.
A crow named Betty is the only non-human creature known to have
invented a tool. Chimps occasionally use twigs and blades of grass to reach
deeper into termite mounds. Beavers use logs and sticks to build dams. But
none of them reshape their raw materials for improved effectiveness. Betty
(documented by Oxford University's Behavioral Ecology Research Group)
deliberately bent a piece of soft wire into a hook, for fishing grubs out of
a tube. She even adjusted the size and shape of the hook so that it would
work better!
It was not a fluke. She did it repeatedly.
And Alex – a 30-year-old African grey parrot – understands the
phonetic sounds associated with letters of the alphabet, and can put those
sounds together into words. Alex has a vocabulary of over 100 words, and is
able to ask questions. He even understands the concept of zero.
Alec has apparently reached the intelligence of a human
five-year-old.
I suspect that crows are too smart to submit to intelligence tests.
As I walked on, the crow let go with a final “Cawww! Caaawwww!” and
flapped off.
I had no difficulty understanding that last message: “Goodbye and
good riddance, earthbound dummy!” |

Jim Taylor
Jim Taylor has more than 40 years experience writing and editing, in
broadcasting, magazines, newspapers, and books. He was for 13 years the managing
editor of a 330,000 circulation magazine; he co-founded a publishing house; he
has written 13 books and has lost count of the number of magazine articles.
Although theoretically retired, he continues to edit two or three books a year,
dispenses advice liberally, and teaches his Eight-Step Editing workshops across
Canada. |